The relationship between landlords and tenants is a crucial aspect of the rental market, yet disputes between the two parties are common in South Africa. Issues such as non-payment of rent, maintenance responsibilities, and deposit disputes can lead to legal battles and financial loss if not handled correctly. Understanding the most frequent conflicts and how to prevent them can create a smoother rental experience for both landlords and tenants.
READ: Rental agreement: Here’s what you need to know
Antonie Goosen, principal and founder of Meridian Realty, highlights the importance of clear communication and legally sound lease agreements. “Many disputes arise because expectations were not set from the beginning. A well-drafted lease agreement that outlines each party’s rights and responsibilities can prevent a lot of headaches down the line,” he explains.
One of the most common disputes is late or unpaid rent, which can place financial strain on landlords and lead to eviction proceedings. To avoid this, it is essential to screen tenants thoroughly, conduct credit checks, and request proof of income to ensure affordability. Having a clear payment policy in the lease agreement, which states the due date, penalties for late payment, and consequences of non-payment, is also critical. Goosen advises that landlords should not wait too long before addressing late payments. “A formal letter of demand should be issued promptly, and legal action taken if necessary,” he says.
Another frequent source of conflict is the question of who is responsible for maintenance and repairs. Tenants expect a well-maintained property, while landlords may be hesitant to cover costs beyond essential repairs. To prevent misunderstandings, the lease should clearly define maintenance responsibilities, specifying which repairs the tenant is responsible for, such as minor wear and tear, and which fall under the landlord’s duties. Goosen notes that responding to maintenance requests promptly is vital, as delays in fixing essential items like plumbing or electricity can frustrate tenants and lead to disputes. Regular inspections also help identify maintenance issues early and prevent larger problems from arising.
READ: How to attract and retain long-term tenants
Security deposit disputes are another major issue, particularly when landlords deduct money at the end of a lease for damages and tenants believe the deductions are unfair. The Rental Housing Act requires both parties to inspect the property together at the start and end of the lease to ensure there is a mutual record of the property’s condition. Documenting damages with photos and providing an itemised breakdown of deductions can help resolve disagreements. The law requires landlords to return the deposit within seven days if no damages are found and within 14 days if deductions are made. Transparency is key in this process.
Lease agreements do not always run their full course, and early termination is another common point of conflict. Situations change, and sometimes tenants need to terminate their lease before the agreed period, leading to disputes over penalties or replacement tenants. Under the Consumer Protection Act, tenants have the right to terminate a lease with 20 business days’ notice but may be liable for reasonable penalties. Goosen advises that landlords should ensure their lease agreement specifies the notice period and potential costs if a tenant leaves early. Working together to find a replacement tenant can minimise financial loss for both parties.
Evictions are a particularly sensitive issue in South Africa, governed by strict legal procedures under the Prevention of Illegal Eviction Act (PIE Act). Attempting to remove a tenant without following the correct legal process can result in serious legal consequences for landlords. Goosen stresses the importance of following the legal eviction process, which requires a letter of demand and a court order before any action can be taken. “Changing locks, cutting off electricity, or physically removing a tenant is illegal and could result in hefty fines or imprisonment,” he warns. Seeking legal advice when eviction becomes necessary ensures compliance with the law.
While disputes may arise, many can be prevented with proactive management, clear agreements, and good communication. Goosen emphasises that mutual respect and professionalism go a long way in avoiding conflicts. “A landlord-tenant relationship should be treated as a partnership. When both parties understand their rights and responsibilities, the rental experience becomes much smoother for everyone involved.” By taking these preventive measures, landlords can protect their investments, and tenants can enjoy a fair and secure renting experience.
What is a lease agreement?
A lease agreement is a legally binding contract between a landlord and a tenant that outlines the terms and conditions of the rental arrangement. A well-drafted lease agreement should cover all aspects of the tenancy, including rent, security deposit, maintenance responsibilities, and tenant obligations. It should also provide a framework for resolving disputes and terminating the tenancy.
Why does a landlord need a watertight lease agreement?
Having a proper lease agreement is essential for landlords for several reasons. Firstly, it helps to establish a clear understanding between the landlord and the tenant about their respective rights and obligations. This can help to prevent misunderstandings or disputes that may arise during the tenancy.
Secondly, a lease agreement can protect the landlord’s property by setting out guidelines for maintenance and repairs. This can help to ensure that the property is maintained in good condition and that any damages caused by the tenant are addressed promptly.
Thirdly, a lease agreement can provide a framework for resolving disputes that may arise during the tenancy. This can help to minimise the risk of costly and time-consuming legal proceedings.
Fourthly, a lease agreement can help to protect the landlord’s financial interests by specifying the terms of rent payments, late fees, and security deposits. This can help to ensure that the landlord receives the rent on time and is adequately compensated for any damages or unpaid rent.
A sound lease agreement is essential
In summary, a well-drafted lease agreement is essential for landlords to protect themselves and their property. It provides a clear understanding of the terms and conditions of the arrangement, establishes guidelines for maintenance and repairs, provides a framework for resolving disputes, and protects the landlord’s financial interests.
Speak to a legal expert
As a landlord, it is important to seek the advice of a legal professional to ensure that your lease agreement complies with all relevant laws and regulations, and is tailored to your specific circumstances.
Abrahams & Gross’s attorneys have considerable legal experience with all matters related to tenants, landlords, lease agreements and dispute resolution. Please contact the Conveyancing and Property Law or Litigation and Dispute Resolution team to assist with your issue.
Author* Abrahams & Gross’s Litigation and Dispute Resolution team
READ: Landlords: A guide to finding the ideal rental candidates
Additional information:
According to the Department of Human Settlements, a Rental Housing Tribunal has the authority to deal with disputes, complaints or problems between tenants and landlords in the rental housing dwellings:
- Non-payment of rentals
- Failure to refund the deposit
- Invasion of tenant’s privacy, including family members and visitors
- Unlawful seizure of tenant’s goods
- Discrimination by landlord against prospective tenants
- The changing of locks
- Lack of maintenance and repairs
- Illegal evictions
- Illegal lockout or illegal disconnection of services
- Damage to property
- Demolition and conversion
- Forced entry
- House rules
- Intimidation
- Issuing of receipts
- Municipal services
- Nuisance
- Overcrowding and health matters
In terms of section 13(13) of the Rental Housing Act 50 of 1999, a ruling of the Tribunal is deemed to be an order of a Magistrate's Court in terms of the Magistrate's Court Act, 1994.
* Disclaimer: The articles on these web pages are provided for general information purposes only. Whilst care has been taken to ensure accuracy, the content provided is not intended to stand alone as legal advice. Always consult a suitably qualified attorney on any specific legal problem or matter.
Want all the latest property news and curated hot property listings sent directly to your inbox? Register for Property24’s Hot Properties, Lifestyle and Weekly Property Trends newsletters or follow us on Twitter, Instagram or Facebook.
Print
